Are Advance Care Directives (ACDs)
just for older people?
No. An ACD can be made by any adult with capacity
over the age of 18 years.
A person, who after adequate education is able to
understand the question at hand, weigh up and understand
the consequences of their own choices is said to have
capacity. This person has the right to make their own
financial, health and lifestyle decisions. All people
are assumed to have capacity unless there is a valid
reason for this to be questioned (eg advancing dementia,
delerium, psychosis, depression etc). In these cases a
capacity assessment can be carried out by the health or
legal professionals involved.
Are ACDs
legally binding?
In NSW (unlike other states), there is no specific
legislation to cover this area. Therefore, ACDs fall
under common law. An ACD is regarded as valid if it is
specific, current, the
person making it had the capacity to
make valid choices and it
helps if the signature has been witnessed
What should be done with an
ACD once it is completed?
An ACD needs to be available at a future time when it
may be needed. Ideally, a copy would be given to the
likely substitute decision maker, key family members,
the GP and any other doctors or health facilities
involved in care.
What if
someone changes their mind?
If circumstances or ideas change, then a new ACD can
be made. The old document is ideally destroyed. If not
however, like a will it is the most recent document that
will apply.
What happens when substitute
decision makers disagree with the documented wishes of a
patient?
The wishes of a competent adult always prevail. Thus,
a valid ACD which expresses wishes regarding active
treatment or refusal of treatment takes priority over
the wishes of the family. It is ideal if someone making
an ACD discusses their directive with their substitute
decision makers so that everyone is already aware of
their wishes.
Is this
another form of euthanasia?
ACDs have nothing to do with actively assisting the
end of life, unlike euthanasia. Studies of nursing home
patients have in fact shown that those with an ACD
requesting avoidance of hospital actually lived longer
than other patients who were transferred to hospital
with an acute illness.
Is this about saving money?
No. ACDs are all about promoting dignity and quality
of life through respecting a person’s own wishes at a
time when they can no longer express these for
themselves. |